Total Pageviews

Showing posts with label Russia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Russia. Show all posts

Saturday, August 24, 2024

Musing on Power and Strength

 The Democratic National Convention wrapped up a couple of days ago, bringing the curtain triumphantly down on a week of amazing excitement, path-breaking and historic moments and joy, so much joy. Yet, as Kamala Harris delivered her speech accepting the nomination and laying out her vision of tomorrow, beyond the happiness and pride, one interesting note struck me more than any others. Unsurprising, perhaps since this was a moment of affirming a muscular approach to the world outside, and that is not an idea one associates with Democrats, much less with a liberal from San Francisco, as Harris' opponents would like to describe her.

 In some ways, the idea of a Democrat arguing that she will ensure America's military remains the most lethal force in the world should not be a surprise. It was Roosevelt who led the USA through World War 2, it was Truman who willingly stood up during the Cold War, it was John Kennedy who remained steadfast through the Cuban missile crisis, Bill Clinton intervened in Yugoslavia to protect Albanians from genocide and it was Obama who reminded the world while accepting the Nobel Peace Prize that he would never flinch from defending American power and interests. While the Democrats may have many voices that speak in softer language and advocate for less violent realpolitik, the leaders have rarely shied away from projecting American power abroad. It is also true that no Democrat nominee for President would use their moment in the brightest spotlight to suggest a new approach.

And, yet, a new approach is exactly what we need. Speaker after speaker echoed the cliched "God bless our troops!", a line that has as much meaning as offering "thoughts and prayers" after yet another mass shooting. I am not naive enough to suggest that America should disengage from the world and withdraw into isolation - a policy more associated with the American right-wing than the left - nor that we should send our forces to act as the world's policeman in troubled corners of the world, from Haiti to Yemen to Niger. Above all, what I hope is that our leaders recognize the difference between force, strength and power. 

At first glance, it may seem that the terms are largely interchangeable, especially strength and power, and there is no doubt that they are deeply connected. Yet, as we can see around us all the time, force and strength are not the same, and strength and power are likewise quite distinct. We know now, after three bloody years of war in Ukraine that Russia was never militarily strong. Their open invasion of Ukraine showed that they could not sustain a military operation just across their border in an area deeply connected to their own logistical network; what chance do they have of fighting further abroad then. Yet, till the moment that their army rolled (metaphorically) across the border, few people doubted their strength, and that illusion of strength gave them power. The moment they employed force however, it stripped away the curtains and showed that they were nothing but a  toothless tiger - dangerous, cruel, ruthless, still and able to inflict tremendous pain on a smaller neighbor, but quite incapable of matching their actions to their bombastic words. Indeed, their deployment of super weapons like hypersonic missiles proved as much a game changer as the V-1 and V-2 flying bombs of Hitler, again able to hurt but far less overwhelming than promised and it is almost beyond question that the Khinzal enjoyed far greater status before it was used. In a similar way, the Ukranian counteroffensive of last year revealed weaknesses in American and West European armor - perhaps as much a function of expectations, conditions and operational mistakes - that deflated the power they had enjoyed before the limitations in their strength were exposed.

It should not be thought that this loss of power is peculiar to Russia and its ilk either. The USA enjoyed its own moment of seemingly incredible power in fall of 2002 - a terrorist attack on New York had destroyed the Twin Towers and America came together in righteous anger, determined to unleash unprecedented retribution on the men who had planned and enabled the attack, and for good measure. And that power would fall upon others with far less connection to the attack but deserving of suffering our wrath because we could. The world watched with bated breath and mostly silent awe as US special forces swept the Taliban from power in Afghanistan, then America toppled the Iraqi dictator with almost ludicrous ease, killing thousands of Iraqi soldiers for a near negligible cost in American blood. And having seemingly demonstrated its strength, America believed its power to be near infinite when it brushed off Iranian overtures. In hindsight, we can see that we had reached the apex of our power and that the use of force was about to undermine our strength and eventually reduce our power, as low-level insurgencies in both Afghanistan and Iraq sapped our wealth and will. We eventually withdrew from both countries with most of our stated aims defeated. The Iranians realized that they were no longer under threat of invasion and began to make their own miscalculations of strength and power.

Over and over, we can see that the use of force reduces our power. An interesting case is playing out in Israel and the Middle East - Iran and Hezbollah have stayed largely on the sidelines and appeared stronger as a result, while any move to engage Israel tends to undercut that power when their actual strength is revealed  to be less than it was supposed. Israel sadly is facing its own dilemma - the terrorist attacks belied Israel's seeming invulnerability and it is now expending a massive amount of firepower to try and restore its position. The jury remains out on whether Israel will emerge stronger or weaker from its operations in Gaza, but it shows the delicate balance between projecting power and using force, with the latter inevitably undermining the former. A slightly different scenario was seen in Europe, when Russia seemed to hold the power over Western Europe through control of Europe's gas supply. Yet Europe's economic strength, with help from the US, soon negated Russian power, while in turn Russia was able to find customers elsewhere and thus weather the West's attempts at using their power to chastise Putin; in both cases, strength on one side overcame power exercised by the other, even without the use of force. Examples can be found is so many places: the Houthis have shown the limits of Western power and continued to attack civilian shipping with impunity, despite punitive strikes by American and allied air forces, yet their own power is built on weak foundations and will vanish if and when the world decides to return to the longer, more expensive route around Africa, leaving Yemen mired in poverty and violence and no better than it was a year ago.

Turning back to Harris, who I hope to see as our next president, I hope that she understands these subtle differences. America is strong, a country blessed with so much natural wealth and resources. The USA is powerful, too, but it is important that we keep that power through wise alliances, for power is multiplied when we act in concert with our allies. We must also always recognize the link between our strength and power - our strength, as the disruptions of the Covid epidemic showed, is not without weakness and we would do well to address the chinks in our armor. And above all, we need to avoid the gratuitous use of force. This is not to say that force may never be used, for their are threats that can be handled only through force, but we should remember the keys to successfully employing force - keeping it calibrated to the provocation, ensuring that we have a clearly defined and achievable goal and above all remembering, that the threat of force is often more effective than force itself. Bismark and Sun Tzu would both recognize the wisdom of the words, "speak softly but carry a big stick". I hope Harris ensures we have a big stick, but I also hope we never have to do more than tap it lightly on the ground at a reminder.





Saturday, January 7, 2012

The Ministry of Peace

In George Orwell's famous "1984", government has been simplified into three ironically named Ministries, with the unending war overseen by the "Ministry of Peace". There was a time in the not so recent past when nations were fairly honest about calling that organization their "War Ministry" (England) or "War Department" (USA). At some point however, after the end of the Second World War, Orwellian thinking crept in, and even as the US prepared to engage the world on battlefields far removed from her shores, it was decided that such distasteful matters be handled by a more benign sounding "Defense Department"; defense of one's homeland after all could not be faulted by the most ardent peaceniks, not even when it involved bombing countries on the far side of the world.

Now, for the second time in two decades, the US is contemplating a major reduction in its defense budget. While the last significant cuts were a peace dividend from the end of the Cold War, they were succeeded by a huge build-up in military forces after the September 11 attacks and the subsequent invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq, and ever increasing involvement in conflicts in Arabia, East Africa, Southeast Asia and elsewhere. The latest round of budget cuts are necessitated by a somber realization that we can no longer afford that heady binge of war spending when our debt is spiraling out of control and nearly every other sector of government is being cut past the bone. But while we may no longer be able to afford such a grandiose war machine, the proposed cuts have nevertheless drawn cries of anguish from many quarters.

It's tempting to dismiss such opposition as nothing more or less than the protests of those who benefit from the military-industrial complex, those with a vested financial in continued war spending, but that would be as much a knee-jerk reaction as the worst of theirs. Rather it is worth asking some hard questions of ourselves, starting with the seven hundred billion question: if a war budget that exceeds one third of the entire world's military spending leaves us feeling so insecure about our safety that even modest cuts provoke such anxiety, is it worth the expenditure at all?

According to GlobalSecurity.org, we not only are the world's highest spender by far, we exceed the next SIX countries combined; once you remove neutral (Sweden, Switzerland, Brazil etc) and friendly (NATO and other European allies, Canada, South Korea, Japan) countries from the list, our spending exceeds the next THIRTY FIVE nations on the list! And yet, I saw an article today that our ability to fight more than one war will be seriously compromised if Obama's proposed restructuring is implemented. In which universe do we expect to actually engage in more than one major war of necessity? And when we talk of wars of necessity, that's hawkishly including the invasion of Afghanistan in that category, a war that was about revenge far more than it was about defending our nation or our national interests. When the military introduced the concept of preparing for two simultaneous wars, they had a plausible if unlikely scenario in mind: a Soviet invasion of western Europe and a North Korean attack across the 38th Parallel. In both places, we had commitments to defend our allies, a national interest in maintaining the security of those places and forces in harm's way, and would feel the need to fight those wars. Today, only the delusional would imagine that we need to game for an open war with Russia - they aren't about to invade western Europe and we have few actual interests in checking Russia's moves against former Soviet republics. To put it bluntly, we have commitments there only insofar as we seek them out by trying to expand our influence in those areas.

North Korea does remain a danger, theoretically, but our forces in South Korea would be insufficient to defeat an invasion. Much of the heavy fighting would have to be done by our ally, till we could get a reinforcing army into action, or alternately seek to slow the North Koreans through air and naval power. Significantly, those are the two branches of the military that would see some increases under Obama's plan. The only other ally that might face a military threat is Taiwan, but for decades it has been obvious that the only way we could defend Taiwan was by naval and air power and the deterrent of our missile system. Again, the reduced defense budget would enhance rather than reduce our capabilities.

In other words, we have little need for an army that's able to fight two wars at one time. The only other war being credibly considered is Iran, but the idea of a land force actually invading Iran is ludicrous. Not only did we find that controlling a smaller nation like Iraq to be more than we wanted, we had the advantage of land routes into the country for our invasion force (two routes till poor planning and diplomacy deprived us of the route from Turkey).  In case of Iran we would have to fight our way ashore with no easy staging area with both Iraq and Pakistan unlikely to offer us assistance, while likely fighting a naval battle to keep the Strait of Hormuz open. While there is no question that the US military can do it, the cost would be high, and the deeper we thrust into Iran the higher the cost - Iran's army may be no match for the US, but it is not as crippled by sanctions as Iraq's was, and their military planners have probably studied the successes of the Saddam Fedayeen in Iraq (the most serious obstacle during our invasion of Iraq) and Hezbollah in their fight with Israel in 2006 . On the heels of two costly and somewhat unsuccessful ventures on either side of Iran, it's almost unthinkable that we would actually attempt a ground invasion; if we did we'd need far more troops than we have even today, prior to any cuts. What that means is that any conflict with Iran will be fought from a distance.


The biggest change proposed in the military is the reduction in Army manpower, and a pivot away from nation building and stabilizing abilities. And that seems like an excellent plan. If we were to assume for a moment that the Army was going to be used in such a role in the near future, which troubled region would we choose? Yemen? Somalia? Dafur? Syria? Pakistan? There is no political will to occupy any of those regions, and no guarantee that such action would contribute in any way to an improvement in their situation. And even should the will exist, which would we choose? How would we choose just one (assuming that we'd still maintain our fighting capability in South Korea) when all of them demand equal response? Rather we will follow our far safer approach of support from beyond the borders, as in Libya or through a military surrogate, like Ethiopia and Kenya in Somalia currently.

Given the near unique position enjoyed by the US, with no hostile neighbors and self-sufficiency or secure sources of all vital resources, it is really amazing that we are proposing so modest a reduction in our war budgets. Attempting to resolve all our challenges and confront all dangers alone and with force is way beyond the capability of our military, even currently. Our better approach would be to evaluate exactly what our vital interests are - perhaps keeping open trade routes through the Strait of Hormuz and the Malacca Straits, abd around the Horn of Africa and - and then working to achieve those aims without force. Keeping a big enough stick handy may be a good idea if all else fails, but carrots can win the same results and are often cheaper. And it's worth remembering that all we need is a big stick not a giant club that may be to heavy to wield and may only end up injuring ourselves.